Home Environment & Climate News Florida Court Tosses Youth Climate Lawsuit

Florida Court Tosses Youth Climate Lawsuit

In another in a string of defeats of lawsuits in which youth plaintiffs are attempting to force governments to take action to fight climate change, Florida Circuit Court Judge Kevin Carroll dismissed a lawsuit brought by eight Florida youths against Gov. Ron DeSantis and Agriculture Commissioner Nikki Fried.

This defeat tracks the history of cases brought by climate activist law firms on behalf youths in Alaska, Montana, Oregon, Washington state, and in a federal case dismissed earlier this year. In those cases, as in the Florida decision, the courts found legislative bodies, not the courts, are the appropriate forum in which to shape states’ and the nation’s climate and energy policies.

No Constitutional Violations

In the case, Reynolds v. State of Florida, the plaintiffs, ranging in age from 12 to 22, alleged state political leaders had violated their constitutional rights to a healthy environment and the public trust doctrine to manage natural resources responsibly, by not taking serious action to prevent climate change and by supporting the continued development and use of fossil fuels.

Florida’s Attorney General’s office argued the state’s public trust doctrine applies only to certain waterways and some shorelines, not the air, and matters of climate and energy policies are for voters and the legislature, not courts, to decide.

Carroll agreed, rejecting the case before it went to trial, saying he concluded climate concerns were more appropriately settled in state capitols and by governors, rather than judges.

“We can’t rely on judges to be dictators of public policy because, at the end of the day, a dictator in a black robe isn’t any better than a dictator in a suit or in a military uniform,” wrote Carroll in the June 1 ruling dismissing the case.

Sterling Burnett, Ph.D. (hsburnett@heartland.org) is the managing editor of Environment & Climate News.

H. Sterling Burnett
H. Sterling Burnett, Ph.D. is a Heartland senior fellow on environmental policy and the managing editor of Environment & Climate News.

1 COMMENT

  1. Howdy! This is my 1st comment here so I just wanted to
    give a quick shout out and say I genuinely enjoy reading through your blog posts.
    Can you recommend any other blogs/websites/forums that cover the
    same topics? Thank you!

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisment -

Most Popular

Senate Approves More Money for Teachers’ Pay, but Tennessee Teachers May Not All Get Raises

By Vivian Jones The Tennessee Senate has approved nearly $43 million for teacher pay, but the new money does not mean all Tennessee teachers will...

NJ Legislators Propose Bipartisan Bill to Tackle State’s Burdensome Red Tape

A bipartisan group of New Jersey state senators has offered legislation to create a regulatory review commission that would conduct cost-benefit analyses of the...

Zoom Privilege: How Lockdowns Made the Rich Richer

By Jordan Schachtel Throughout the pandemic, most people have been struggling financially, while the world’s rich simply got richer—many billionaires saw their net worths skyrocket...

Approach to Treating COVID-19 is Wrong, Say Doctors – Interview

Peter McCullough, M.D., M.P.H., is an internist, cardiologist, and epidemiologist at Baylor University Medical Center who has been leading the charge on early, at-home...
- Advertisement -

Recent Comments

Randy M Verret on The Gaslight Election
S. T. Karnick on The Gaslight Election
Randy M Verret on The Gaslight Election
S. T. Karnick on The Gaslight Election
Randy M Verret on The Gaslight Election
S. T. Karnick on The Gaslight Election
Randy Verret on The Gaslight Election
Randy Verret on The Gaslight Election