HomeHealth Care NewsAre Colleges Overdoing it with COVID Testing and Masks? - Commentary

Are Colleges Overdoing it with COVID Testing and Masks? – Commentary

By Lela Gallery

I am all for following rules to keep people safe, and I am not against wearing masks. However, I am also for common sense, and some of my school’s rules are redundant.

I’ve tested negative for COVID 17 times. Ditto my whole floor, residence hall, and every student on campus — we’re required to test twice per week, after all. It’s safe to say that if someone got COVID, it’s been caught, and that person is quarantining.

However, Mt. Holyoke College’s Community Compact says that “masks or cloth face coverings are required when in the presence of others and when outside of your personal room — including outdoors.”

It doesn’t matter what the conditions are. I can be walking outside–without a single soul in sight–and I still have to wear a mask. I can be sitting alone in one of the massive common rooms my school offers, and yet, I still need to wear a mask.

If I peek my head outside of my dorm, I would need to cover my mouth and nose. If I get caught exposing my entire bare face, I could have that infraction put on my record — or even worse — kicked off-campus.

According to my school’s COVID dashboard, we’ve had a total of 33 positive COVID tests this semester for a test positivity rate of .2 percent. This stat covers the roughly 900 students, faculty, and staff on-campus.

The Campus Bubble

We wear a mask to avoid infecting others, but it is unlikely transmission of the virus will happen. There are scarcely any social events on campus, and when there are, the present parties have gone through all of the testing protocols. Most of us have hung out with the same group of people since January.

We’re in a rural area in Massachusetts where cases have dropped since we’ve arrived. We can only travel within a 10-mile radius off-campus. Most of us are too busy cooped up in our dorms attending Zoom classes to go anywhere.

Demographically, we are at the lowest risk for COVID mortality. Most of the students are young and robust between the ages of 17-23.

According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), people under age 45 represent  2.5 percent of all COVID deaths. According to the Heritage Foundation, based on CDC data, people under 25 represent only .2 percent of all COVID fatalities.

The 2018-2019 flu mortality rate for all people ages 18 to 49, a wide range that could include both legal adults and their parents, is 1.8 percent.

 My university’s rules, if applied to other diseases, would be absurd. Imagine if masks were mandatory because of the flu–and not just during flu season, but all year round. We would be required to wear a mask at all times, too, whenever we’re outside our homes, even though everyone around us was healthy, has recently tested negative, acquired immunity because they recovered from COVID or were vaccinated. All of us would think this rule would be ridiculous. So why do we enforce these kinds of regulations among a healthy demographic for a virus with a low mortality rate?

Let Us Breathe

I’m not saying COVID doesn’t exist, and I’m certainly not denying the science. I know many people who were infected with the virus, and it’s something to be taken seriously. However, considering how draconian the laws are, I’ve grown very skeptical of the lockdown policies, and I think there are better ways to prevent the virus without suffocating ourselves.

Let us breathe. If we’re walking to the bathroom, alone in a public room, walking solo, among a group of people who have all tested negative: let us free our mouths. It’s unlikely we’ll pass the virus among others or get infected. For those that do test positive, put them in quarantine.

If we test negative and live among those who have no signs of the virus, there’s no need for us to wear a mask. My peers and I are intelligent and should continue to quarantine ourselves if we have symptoms of COVID, just like we would if we experienced flu symptoms. Universities should encourage hygienic behaviors, too. But we can keep each other safe without depriving ourselves of oxygen and a social life.

Lela Gallery is a student at Mount Holyoke College. This article originally was published by The College Fix on March 19. Reprinted with permission.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


Most Popular

- Advertisement -spot_img
- Advertisement -spot_img

Recent Comments