Home Health Care News Presumption of Guilt: Physicians Blamed for Racial Health Disparities - Commentary

Presumption of Guilt: Physicians Blamed for Racial Health Disparities – Commentary

Efforts to raise awareness about racism and “implicit racial bias” in health care are forcing some doctors to speak out – carefully.

In March, an editor at the Journal of the American Medical Society (JAMA) was fired because he said in a podcast that it was unfortunate the word “racism” taints a valuable discussion on disparate outcomes in health care.

Physicians make a huge investment of time, money, and energy to become medical doctors and are reluctant to make waves with government regulators or powerful special interests. Implicit bias training is now a requirement with at least one insurance company to get credentials and may soon be mandated for medical licensing. Physicians undergo this training at their own time and expense.

We can expect more of this woke guilt-mongering. On April 8, the director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Rochelle Walensky, addressed “ethnic health inequities.” “A growing body of research shows that centuries of racism in this country has had a profound and negative impact on communities of color,”  stated Walensky.

This was not a platitude but a call to action. Walensky said “confronting the impact of racism will not be easy. I know that we can do this if we work together.”

Additionally, there is little to no evidence that health care disparities are the result of medical professionals acting on racist ideologies. Blacks suffered disproportionately from COVID-19, but science shows this has more to do with factors like population density than subconscious bigotry. If science can’t back up their claims, politicians should apologize for suggesting health care providers are racists and remove any orders to address “implicit bias.” Looking at public policy problems through the lens of race is in itself a form of racism. It reduces problems to racial identity groups.  This was not Dr. Martin Luther King’s vision in this famous “I Have a Dream Speech.” Do woke warriors think about that?

Below are the thoughts of one practicing physician who wishes to remain anonymous.

Eat Your Heart Out, George Orwell

“My state has a race problem and so does the nation,” the physician said. “Elected leaders, however, are only exacerbating this problem and using the pandemic as their pretext.

“In the early phases of the COVID-19 pandemic, a marked mortality difference existed between racial groups,” the physician said. “Instead of recognizing the reasons behind this difference are complex and multivariate, the governor of the state where I practice, Michigan, took the easy route and attributed all differences in COVID mortality to racism.

“Governor Gretchen Whitmer acted on this false assumption in July 2020, when under the guise of combating racism she mandated that all healthcare workers undergo ‘implicit bias’ training,” the physician said. “To be implemented in the near future, this training is to be administered by the Department of Licensing and Regulatory Affairs (LARA). Anyone refusing this ‘training’ will lose their license and the ability to practice medicine.

“Suffering such punishment would effectively destroy a healthcare worker’s career,” the physician said. “Worse, the training could reduce the number of healthcare workers during a pandemic when they are most needed.

“Setting a dangerous precedent, Blue Cross Blue Shield (BCBS) jumped on the racism bandwagon in November 2020, requiring implicit bias training for all of its contracted physicians,” the physician said. “Refusing this political indoctrination could lead to professional ruin. Doctors might lose their hospital privileges and their base of patients. BCBS dominates 66 percent of the market.

“Most people agree there is a need to combat overt bias,” the physician said. “However, the claim is that implicit bias is bias so subtle that the person harboring it is not even aware that they have it. Thus, implicit bias training is not the Orwellian ‘1984’ policing of the content of thought but is the policing of subconscious thought.

“Unlike the dystopic Big Brother, neither Big Government nor Big Insurance has the ability to detect thoughts, much as less detect thoughts that you did not consciously think,” the physician said. “Thus, it is patently absurd to claim that they can train you to ‘un-think’ thoughts that you did not consciously think.”

Ignores the Root of the Problem

“By attributing disparities in early COVID mortality to subconscious thought processes, government and special interests ignore the root cause of the problem and block any chance of finding a solution,” the physician said.

“Early in the pandemic, no treatments existed for COVID-19,” the physician said. “At that time, African Americans made up 40 percent of the deaths while only making up 13.6 percent of the population. Such a massive difference in outcomes could not be explained by subtle, unconscious, ‘implicit’ bias. With no known treatments, it could not be explained by explicit bias as there was no treatment for a biased individual to withhold. If based solely on asymmetric racial treatment, the only way such a massive difference in mortality could exist would be from outright murder.

“This extrapolated accusation is why many healthcare workers take great umbrage with the simple-minded ‘racism’ explanation of those such as Whitmer,” the physician said. “Further, physicians are angered as these baseless claims exacerbate distrust by our communities of color causing them to avoid vaccination further imperiling their health.

“I don’t deny that bias exists,” the physician said. “We should all look into our own hearts to be sure we are living up to the ideals espoused by the Reverend Martin Luther King Jr. to judge by the content of one’s character instead of the color of one’s skin. Claims of implicit bias and forced “bias” training do the exact opposite. It is indifferent to character and places all judgment on skin color.

“That seems pretty biased to me,” the physician said. “Perhaps a better way to combat the problem of bias is to place less emphasis on skin color and the new, racially-obsessed religious belief of ‘woke’ Marxist theory and instead return to the timeless, racially-blind, classical religious teaching, ‘Do onto others as you would have them do onto you,’ (Luke 6:31).”


AnneMarie Schieber (amschieber@heartland.org) is the managing editor of Health Care News. A version of this article was published by American Thinker on April 7. Reprinted with permission.







AnneMarie Schieber
AnneMarie Schieber is a research fellow at The Heartland Institute and managing editor of Health Care News, Heartland's monthly newspaper for health care reform.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisment -

Most Popular

This Week in the Heartland Daily News

Eileen Griffin covers the biggest stories from this week in the Heartland Daily News. https://youtu.be/CyUEg4xvI_c Referenced stories: Biden's California Dream Stop Social Media Censorship Act Proposed In Rhode...

Fracking Ban Threatens American Jobs and Derails Our Environmental Progress

Banning fracking ignores sound science in favor of a false choice between environmental quality and natural gas. With the increase of natural gas consumption, particularly in power generation, the U.S. has reduced carbon dioxide emissions to their lowest levels in a generation.

Americans Should ‘Just Say No’ to Vaccine Passports – Commentary

"The truth, understood by well-balanced adults, is that there is no safety in this world, and our overlords’ attempts after a chimerical perfect safety are far more dangerous than any viral disease."

Restrictions, Masks Fail to Stop COVID, Fauci Confused

States with some of the strictest orders to contain the spread of COVID-19 are seeing a surge in new cases, according to an analysis by NPR.
- Advertisement -

Recent Comments

Scottar Brooke on Free Speech? Forget It.
Randy M Verret on The Gaslight Election
S. T. Karnick on The Gaslight Election
Randy M Verret on The Gaslight Election
S. T. Karnick on The Gaslight Election
Randy M Verret on The Gaslight Election
S. T. Karnick on The Gaslight Election
Randy Verret on The Gaslight Election
Randy Verret on The Gaslight Election